Episode: 1x14 (Season 1 Episode 14) Name: I Shall Believe Originally Aired: Feb. 17, 2004 Plot: After the accident, Karen refuses to leave Lucas' bedside as he lays in a coma. There Karen meets Brooke, Lucas' new girlfriend and Deb tells her that she's decided to divorce Dan. However, Karen is delivered the most devastating news when she is informed that Keith was drinking and driving the night of the accident. Meanwhile, Nathan tries to win back Haley after she breaks up with him.