Episode: 1x18 (Season 1 Episode 18) Name: To Wish Impossible Things Originally Aired: Apr. 13, 2004 Plot: At Tree Hill High's annual "Boy Toy" basketball charity auction, Lucas, Nathan, Jake and the rest of the team (as well as Mouth) are sold to the highest bidder. The auction pairs up Lucas and Haley, Nathan and Peyton, Jake and Nicki, and Mouth and Brooke for the night, resulting in Haley confessing her true feelings about Nathan to Lucas and surprising developments in Jake and Nicki's complex relationship.