Episode: 2x20 (Season 2 Episode 20) Name: Lifetime Piling Up Originally Aired: May. 10, 2005 Plot: While in a coma after his racing accident, Nathan has a bizarre dream about what life would be like had Dan chosen Karen over Deb. In this dream, Lucas and Nathan have polar opposite lives than what they have in reality -- Lucas grew up in a privileged world while Deb and Nathan struggled to make ends meet. Meanwhile, when Nathan wakes up he tells Haley he doesn't want her to come home and Deb continues to face her pill addiction.