Episode: 2x21 (Season 2 Episode 21) Name: What Could Have Been Originally Aired: May. 17, 2005 Plot: After his hospital stay following the accident, Nathan comes home to a pile of medical bills. To help him financially, Lucas and Peyton throw Nathan and movie night fundraiser at TRIC. Meanwhile, Dan brings Nathan annulment papers, then visits Haley on tour to have her sign them after he convinces Nathan to end his marriage. Elsewhere, Brooke decides she wants to be more than friends with Lucas, but hesitates to let him in a second time.