Episode: 4x08 (Season 4 Episode 08) Name: Nothing Left To Say But Goodbye Originally Aired: Nov. 22, 2006 Plot: Derek finally convinces Peyton to follow her heart and be with Lucas just as Brooke decides that she wants to get back together with him. Both Nathan and Rachel turn to unlikely people for help -- Nathan to his father for help with Daunte's latest demand and Rachel to Haley for tutoring after she receives an F. Meanwhile, at the annual Ravens sports banquet Nathan is named the team's MVP of the year.